Like many people, I spent the last few days checking The Cincinnati Zoo’s facebook page for updates on Fiona the hippo, a beloved member of the zoo family who captured the hearts of people across the world when she was born prematurely in 2017. Over the next two years, the zoo care team worked tirelessly to feed her, keep her warm, and eventually integrate her back into the hippo enclosure, sharing her journey with the world through social media and the very popular “Fiona Show”.
About a week ago, a knit hat fell into into the hippo enclosure and was swallowed by Fiona. Zoo staff spent several days trying every available strategy to doula the hat through Fiona’s intestinal system, but they were ultimately unsuccessful. Sadly, Fiona passed away yesterday afternoon.
Once again, everyone on the Internet is talking about Fiona. They’re sharing memories and condolences and collective mourning, but they’re also talking about something else.
After seeing the update about Fiona’s death on Facebook, I made the truly dumb decision to look at the comments. Everyone wanted to know how the hat got there, and let me tell you, they were out for blood.
The official explanation from the zoo is that a small child tossed the hat into the air, which happened to catch on the ceiling fan, and was flung through a 1 foot opening at the very top of the 12 foot high glass walls surrounding the enclosure. A spokesman from the zoo said they, “probably couldn’t make [it] happen again if we tried.”
It was the definition of a series of unfortunate events.
But the Internet is not satisfied with freak accidents. They want accountability. They want someone to blame, and they want them to pay dearly.
And that person is, always, the mother.
The comments are ablaze with accusations. She must have been on her phone. The child was tossing the hat over and over and the parent didn’t even care. She wasn’t paying enough attention. She needed to get control over her kid. Parents need to discipline their kids. Kids are spoiled brats these days.
And then the more vindictive comments: The family should be banned from the zoo for life. They should have to pay all the medical bills. A few people even suggested they be arrested.
I felt my stomach turn queasy as I read through the responses, because, of course, I am that mom.
My child didn’t throw the hat that day, but my kids have acted a fool at a zoo, and a grocery store, and a church. They have thrown a fit or thrown an object.
I like to believe I am a pretty decent mom, and I know some really fantastic moms. They are moms that pay attention, set boundaries, and work really hard to make sure their kids are not spoiled brats.
And still, sometimes kids do dumb shit. I don’t know a single mother whose child hasn’t done something unforeseeable and a little bit unhinged. Things that are truly weirder and worse than tossing a hat into the air.
And the reality is, I don’t always catch it immediately. Sometimes I have my phone out to answer a text from my husband or check a grocery order or, God forbid, try to capture a picture of them having a fun day at the zoo.
Sometimes my attention is occupied by another child. Sometimes I am tired and mentally calculating which battle is worth fighting today. Would I have seen tossing a hat into the air as an immediate shut-it-down emergency? I don’t know for sure, but probably not. Does this make me a terrible mother who deserves to never enter a zoo again, go into medical debt, and be arrested? According to the Internet, it does.
If this mom is anything like me (and she’s probably more like me than not), she is already mortified. I would’ve begged for the floor to swallow me up when that hippo swallowed that hat. There is no Internet beratement that could be worse than what my mind would’ve already lobbed at me.
She has probably replayed every second of that scenario six hundred times and thought of all the things she could’ve done differently. She doesn’t need the Internet to remind her that she messed up, because she already believes it, and she knows you aren’t allowed to mess up once your a mom.
Is it any wonder so many of us are anxious wrecks? In one breath, we’re told helicopter parenting is turning our kids into useless, dependent, toddler-adults, and in the next, we’re told we need to have control over them at every second.
We’re trying to raise our children in environments where they’re allowed to make mistakes, to learn and grow, to try and fail, and to be caught in the safety net of home.
But there is no safety net for moms, no one to give grace when we aren’t perfect. We are supposed to have it all figured out. In every moment, we are expected to be available and tuned in. We are supposed to know the magic words that will result in immediate compliance no matter the situation. We are taught to be hyper-vigilant, aware of 10,000 dangers that could be present in any given situation. We should have an answer for every unpredictable, unanticipatable thing our children will do, and not even dare to allow them to exist in a public space until we do.
Never mind, neurodivergence. Never mind, disabilities! Never mind the fact that their pre-frontal cortexes won’t be developed for another two decades! Never mind that all of us, all the time, are still 100% human beings, messy and unpredictable and prone to making mistakes. Kids should be behaved, respectful, and obedient at all times, and if they aren’t, it’s definitely the mom’s fault.
My brain understands this is an impossible ask, but it still talks to me like it isn’t. It still tells me I should be doing more, doing better. It still feels absolutely mortified and like a rotten, miserable failure when my kids roughhouse in an aisle at Aldi or get so angry that they hurt each other. My brain repeats to me what its seen on the internet, whispering, judging: geez, Courtney, if you would just get control of your kids.
I am truly devastated for Fiona and for the care team who has been with her for so many years, and who worked so hard to save her. I’m sad for all of us, too. Fiona was a symbol of hope and resilience, and she brought delight and wonder to a world that desperately needs more delight and wonder. She was also a part of a zoo system that offers one of the few places that feels genuinely accessible and welcoming for families—including eager, unpredictable, rambunctious kids.
Freak accidents are terrible, and they cause real damage. They’re also terrifying. It’s easier to think that this parent was negligent and irresponsible than to imagine that something this bizarre, with this severe of consequences, could happen to any of us.
I’m scared to parent in this world, where my child could do something as benign as toss a hat into the air, and I could be placed on the Internet stake to be burned for all eternity. And I don’t want the real mom of that child to live in that world either.
I hope she isn’t terrified of her identity being uncovered and the danger that could bring to her family. I hope she finds some grace for herself amidst all the shame. And merciful God, I hope she’s not reading the comments.
I’m not interested in piling on a parent who, in all likelihood, was just trying to enjoy an ordinary day at the zoo with her kids. What I am interested in is turning this fervor for accountability towards people who have committed actual crimes. Not people who have experienced a one in a million freak accident, but people who have caused deliberate, criminal harm, often to children. Maybe once we’ve got that sorted out, we can turn our attention towards moms of kids throwing hats.




