Thanksgiving is the Super Bowl for food bloggers: the event we plan for, test for, and and think about almost all year long. Each year, I try to add a new recipe (or four!) to our menu, as well as go back and update or re-test recipes as needed. After 15 years of doing this work, we have quite a collection!
I’ll point you first to our 🌟 Complete Mix and Match Thanksgiving Menu 🌟, with 70 recipes(!!) for every part of the meal: from main dish to dessert. Each one is labeled for Make Ahead Friendly, Gluten Free, and Vegetarian, so you can flex with different dietary or prep needs. I’ve got all the traditional options (a beginner friendly roast turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing), but also some non-traditional options. If you’re going fully non-traditional, I recommend checking out this post.
Non-Traditional Thanksgiving Meal Ideas
For many reasons, I am often sick of Thanksgiving food by the time Thanksgiving day arrives. By the end of November, I’ve spent months testing turkey and dinner rolls, and all I really want is a big salad or perhaps a nice juicy bowl of cereal.
I also want to point you to some of my newer favorites, added this last year:
Some Hosting Tips
🌟 ASK FOR HELP. Pick one thing from each food category and assign it to your guests. My niece led the way on this last year, and it was such a great example of exercising generous authority as a host. She texted each of the guests with an assignment (ie: Courtney- Potato side dish, Katie- Stuffing, Mom- Bread, etc. etc). It freed her up to focus on just one or two things, and gave us each a clear expectation with a little wiggle room within the category.
Other things you might ask for help with: table decorations, centerpieces, coming early to help set up.
🌟 Thaw your turkey! If you take absolutely nothing else from this post, it is this. You need AT LEAST three full days to thaw a 12-15 lb turkey in the fridge and an extra day for a larger one. A frozen turkey is the easiest way to have a panic attack on Thanksgiving morning.
🌟 Crank that thermostat down. It doesn’t matter how cold it is, if I’m hosting and cooking, I feel like I’m the turkey being roasted if I don’t turn the heat down. The space warms up as people enter anyway, so it doesn’t hurt to start with a cooler temperature.
🌟 Check your supplies now, not the day before. I am notoriously bad at this, but I’m learning and growing. About a week out, check that you have everything you need to host: enough place settings and chairs for all guests, toilet paper, and serving dishes. You can actually take out all your serving dishes and place a post-it note on them with what they’ll hold to make sure everything has a place. You can also make your grocery list and check your supply on basics like spices, oils, parchment paper, and cooking spray. Doing this now gives you time to ask neighbors or family members if you can borrow a folding chair or a few extra pieces of silverware, saving you from running out and trying to find a drink pitcher the day before Thanksgiving (ask me how I’ve learned this lesson!!).
🌟 If it will help you enjoy the day, use paper plates. We pick up fancier paper plates for holiday gatherings and I never regret it. It helps everyone relax and have more time to be present and enjoy the day.
🌟 Make as much as you can ahead of time. Paid subscribers, you can find my full printable make-ahead guide below, detailing what to make ahead of time, when to take things out of the fridge or freezer, and how to plan the day so everything is ready at a reasonable hour.
Most importantly, I want you to know YOU CAN DO THIS. Whether you’re making a turkey for the first time, hosting for the first (or twentieth) time, or experimenting with a new recipe, you’ve got this. It doesn’t have to be perfect. There will most likely be one or several things that go a bit haywire. There will probably be very big feelings, and that’s okay too. If ever there was a day for an abundance of grace, it’s Thanksgiving. If you need a little breather, please read our Thanksgiving affirmations, and remember I’m here to cheer you on!

Paid subscribers, I appreciate you so much! Get your full schedule below!





